Migrating CORBA Applications from BOA to POA

Contents

• Client-side Changes
• Server-side Changes
• Reference counting Servants

Client-side Changes

• Very little has changed. Thus, many applications require no changes.

Server-side Changes

• POA_init is replaced with resolve_initial_references("RootPOA") followed by a _narrow operation.
• The implementation no longer inherits from the client-side stub. Instead, they inherit from PortableServer::ServantBase. The implications of this are (a) if you want a object reference for that, you must use the _this method.
• Object ID's are assigned by the POA unless you activate the servant with a specific ID. IDL_Cubit has examples on how to do this.
• Unlike the BOA, the POA explicitly addresses the temporal nature of servants and declares that a POA can service either transient or persistent servants (not both). The root POA's (mandated, unchangeable) policy is "transient". The implications of this are that in order for a client to be able to manufacture an object reference on its own and use that to access an object, the servant for that object must be registered with a POA whose policy is "persistent". Thus, you must create a child POA with that policy and register the servant with that POA. NOTE: when the POA declares something as "persistent", it is only stating that the key is valid between different runs of the server; it makes no claims that state or anything else is persistent.
• Servants are not automatically activated, hence you must register them by calling some of the activate_object* methods on a POA or calling _this on the servant; with the latest you have no control on the ObjectId (which sometimes is good), and the POA must support the right policies (the RootPOA does).
• Servant constructors use to take a const char* parameter to set they object id, this is not needed now, in fact in many cases they use to pass this argument to the skeleton class: this will fail now.

This list is not intended to be exhaustive, but should give you a good starting point. If you find things along the way that change your applications and I didn't note them, please send them to me. Perhaps we can work together on the ultimate migration document.

Reference counting Servants

• If a servant is deleted without deactivating from the POA, the application will crash because the POA will try to access the still registered (but now non-existent) servant when the POA is destroyed.

  The solution to this is to make sure that the servant is deleted after the POA is deleted or make sure that the servant is deactivated from the POA before the servant is deleted.

• You cannot delete a servant which is the target of the current upcall/request. A good example of this is the typical destroy() method, usually written like this:

  
  class TAO_Export TAO_Thread_Policy : public POA_PortableServer::ThreadPolicy
  {
    void destroy (CORBA_Environment &ACE_TRY_ENV);
  };
  
  void
  TAO_Thread_Policy::destroy (CORBA::Environment &ACE_TRY_ENV)
  {
    PortableServer::POA_var poa = this->_default_POA (ACE_TRY_ENV);
    ACE_CHECK;
  
    PortableServer::ObjectId_var id = poa->servant_to_id (this,
                                                          ACE_TRY_ENV);
    ACE_CHECK;
  
    poa->deactivate_object (id.in (),
                            ACE_TRY_ENV);
    ACE_CHECK;
  
    // Commit suicide: must have been dynamically allocated.
    delete this;
  }
  
  

  The correct implementation is:

  
  class TAO_Export TAO_Thread_Policy : public virtual PortableServer::RefCountServantBase,
                                       public virtual POA_PortableServer::ThreadPolicy
  {
    void destroy (CORBA_Environment &ACE_TRY_ENV);
  };
  
  void
  TAO_Thread_Policy::destroy (CORBA::Environment &ACE_TRY_ENV)
  {
    //
    // Remove self from POA.  Because of reference counting, the POA
    // will automatically delete the servant when all pending requests
    // on this servant are complete.
    //
  
    PortableServer::POA_var poa = this->_default_POA (ACE_TRY_ENV);
    ACE_CHECK;
  
    PortableServer::ObjectId_var id = poa->servant_to_id (this,
                                                          ACE_TRY_ENV);
    ACE_CHECK;
  
    poa->deactivate_object (id.in (),
                            ACE_TRY_ENV);
    ACE_CHECK;
  }
  
  

  One additional step required is to make the POA responsible for the servant after it has been registered with the POA:

  
    // Register with the POA.
    PortableServer::ThreadPolicy_var result = new_thread_policy->_this (ACE_TRY_ENV);
  
    // Give ownership of this servant to the POA.
    new_thread_policy->_remove_ref (ACE_TRY_ENV);
  
  

  If you use the above approach of multiple inheritance, you must add the following to your header file:

  
  // This is to remove "inherits via dominance" warnings from MSVC.
  // MSVC is being a little too paranoid.
  #if defined (_MSC_VER)
  # pragma warning (disable : 4250)
  #endif /* _MSC_VER */
  
  

  To see the above example in detail, checkout TAO/examples/POA/Reference_Counted_Servant and/or Root_POA.cpp and Root_POA.h.

Back to the TAO documentation page.