To invoke a method on a local or remote stateless session bean, client code must normally perform a JNDI lookup to obtain the (local or remote) EJB Home object, then use a 'create' method call on that object to obtain the actual (local or remote) EJB object. One or more methods are then invoked on the EJB.
To avoid repeated low-level code, many EJB applications use the Service Locator and Business Delegate patterns. These are better than spraying JNDI lookups throughout client code, but their usual implementations have significant disadvantages. For example:
Typically code using EJBs depends on Service Locator or Business Delegate singletons, making it hard to test.
In the case of the Service Locator pattern used without a Business Delegate, application code still ends up having to invoke the create() method on an EJB home, and deal with the resulting exceptions. Thus it remains tied to the EJB API and the complexity of the EJB programming model.
Implementing the Business Delegate pattern typically results in significant code duplication, where we have to write numerous methods that simply call the same method on the EJB.
The Spring approach is to allow the creation and use of proxy objects, normally configured inside a Spring container, which act as codeless business delegates. You do not need to write another Service Locator, another JNDI lookup, or duplicate methods in a hand-coded Business Delegate unless you are actually adding real value in such code.
Assume that we have a web controller that needs to use a local
EJB. We’ll follow best practice and use the EJB Business Methods
Interface pattern, so that the EJB’s local interface extends a non
EJB-specific business methods interface. Let’s call this business
methods interface MyComponent
.
public interface MyComponent { ... }
One of the main reasons to use the Business Methods Interface pattern
is to ensure that synchronization between method signatures in local
interface and bean implementation class is automatic. Another reason is
that it later makes it much easier for us to switch to a POJO (plain old
Java object) implementation of the service if it makes sense to do so.
Of course we’ll also need to implement the local home interface and
provide an implementation class that implements SessionBean
and the MyComponent
business methods interface. Now the
only Java coding we’ll need to do to hook up our web tier controller to the
EJB implementation is to expose a setter method of type MyComponent
on the controller. This will save the reference as an instance variable in the
controller:
private MyComponent myComponent; public void setMyComponent(MyComponent myComponent) { this.myComponent = myComponent; }
We can subsequently use this instance variable in any business
method in the controller. Now assuming we are obtaining our controller
object out of a Spring container, we can (in the same context) configure a
LocalStatelessSessionProxyFactoryBean
instance, which
will be the EJB proxy object. The configuration of the proxy, and setting of
the myComponent
property of the controller is done
with a configuration entry such as:
<bean id="myComponent" class="org.springframework.ejb.access.LocalStatelessSessionProxyFactoryBean"> <property name="jndiName" value="ejb/myBean"/> <property name="businessInterface" value="com.mycom.MyComponent"/> </bean> <bean id="myController" class="com.mycom.myController"> <property name="myComponent" ref="myComponent"/> </bean>
There’s a lot of work happening behind the scenes, courtesy of
the Spring AOP framework, although you aren’t forced to work with AOP
concepts to enjoy the results. The myComponent
bean
definition creates a proxy for the EJB, which implements the business
method interface. The EJB local home is cached on startup, so there’s
only a single JNDI lookup. Each time the EJB is invoked, the proxy
invokes the classname
method on the local EJB and
invokes the corresponding business method on the EJB.
The myController
bean definition sets the
myComponent
property of the controller class to the
EJB proxy.
Alternatively (and preferably in case of many such proxy definitions),
consider using the <jee:local-slsb>
configuration element in Spring's "jee" namespace:
<jee:local-slsb id="myComponent" jndi-name="ejb/myBean" business-interface="com.mycom.MyComponent"/> <bean id="myController" class="com.mycom.myController"> <property name="myComponent" ref="myComponent"/> </bean>
This EJB access mechanism delivers huge simplification of
application code: the web tier code (or other EJB client code) has no
dependence on the use of EJB. If we want to replace this EJB reference
with a POJO or a mock object or other test stub, we could simply change
the myComponent
bean definition without changing a
line of Java code. Additionally, we haven’t had to write a single line of
JNDI lookup or other EJB plumbing code as part of our application.
Benchmarks and experience in real applications indicate that the performance overhead of this approach (which involves reflective invocation of the target EJB) is minimal, and is typically undetectable in typical use. Remember that we don’t want to make fine-grained calls to EJBs anyway, as there’s a cost associated with the EJB infrastructure in the application server.
There is one caveat with regards to the JNDI lookup. In a bean
container, this class is normally best used as a singleton (there simply
is no reason to make it a prototype). However, if that bean container
pre-instantiates singletons (as do the various XML
ApplicationContext
variants)
you may have a problem if the bean container is loaded before the EJB
container loads the target EJB. That is because the JNDI lookup will be
performed in the init()
method of this class and then
cached, but the EJB will not have been bound at the target location yet.
The solution is to not pre-instantiate this factory object, but allow it
to be created on first use. In the XML containers, this is controlled via
the lazy-init
attribute.
Although this will not be of interest to the majority of Spring
users, those doing programmatic AOP work with EJBs may want to look at
LocalSlsbInvokerInterceptor
.
Accessing remote EJBs is essentially identical to accessing local
EJBs, except that the
SimpleRemoteStatelessSessionProxyFactoryBean
or
<jee:remote-slsb>
configuration element is used.
Of course, with or without Spring, remote invocation semantics apply; a
call to a method on an object in another VM in another computer does
sometimes have to be treated differently in terms of usage scenarios and
failure handling.
Spring's EJB client support adds one more advantage over the
non-Spring approach. Normally it is problematic for EJB client code to
be easily switched back and forth between calling EJBs locally or
remotely. This is because the remote interface methods must declare that
they throw RemoteException
, and client code must deal
with this, while the local interface methods don't. Client code
written for local EJBs which needs to be moved to remote EJBs
typically has to be modified to add handling for the remote exceptions,
and client code written for remote EJBs which needs to be moved to local
EJBs, can either stay the same but do a lot of unnecessary handling of
remote exceptions, or needs to be modified to remove that code. With the
Spring remote EJB proxy, you can instead not declare any thrown
RemoteException
in your Business Method Interface and
implementing EJB code, have a remote interface which is identical except
that it does throw RemoteException
, and rely on the
proxy to dynamically treat the two interfaces as if they were the same.
That is, client code does not have to deal with the checked
RemoteException
class. Any actual
RemoteException
that is thrown during the EJB
invocation will be re-thrown as the non-checked
RemoteAccessException
class, which is a subclass of
RuntimeException
. The target service can then be
switched at will between a local EJB or remote EJB (or even plain Java
object) implementation, without the client code knowing or caring. Of
course, this is optional; there is nothing stopping you from declaring
RemoteExceptions
in your business interface.
Accessing EJB 2.x Session Beans and EJB 3 Session Beans via Spring
is largely transparent. Spring's EJB accessors, including the
<jee:local-slsb>
and <jee:remote-slsb>
facilities, transparently adapt to the actual component at runtime.
They handle a home interface if found (EJB 2.x style), or perform straight
component invocations if no home interface is available (EJB 3 style).
Note: For EJB 3 Session Beans, you could effectively use a
JndiObjectFactoryBean
/ <jee:jndi-lookup>
as well, since fully usable component references are exposed for plain
JNDI lookups there. Defining explicit <jee:local-slsb>
/ <jee:remote-slsb>
lookups simply provides
consistent and more explicit EJB access configuration.